List of Ministers
| James E. Varney | 1733-1739 |
| Isaac Morrill | 1741-1793 |
| Freegrace Raynolds | 1794-1830 |
| Francis Norwood | 1831-1842 |
| Barnabas M. Fay | 1845-1850 |
| Joseph E. Swallow | 1851-1856 |
| Samuel H. Tolman | 1856-1870 |
| Benjamin A. Robie | 1871-1874 |
| Samuel S. Mathews | 1874-1875 |
| Daniel P. Noyes | 1877-1885 |
| Elijah Harmon | 1885-1900 |
| Walter H. Rollins | 1900-1906 |
| George J. Bloomfield | 1906-1917 |
| Halah H. Loud | 1917-1921 |
| Benjamin F. Schwarts | 1921-1922 |
| William C. Perdew | 1922-1923 |
| Arthur A. Simmons | 1924-1939 |
| Clyde M. Martin | 1939-1947 |
| Stanley Cummings | 1948-1958 |
| Robert E. Sanders | 1959-1965 |
| H. Allen Tadgell | 1966-1973 |
| George B. Taylor III | 1973-1978 |
| William L. Murdoch | 1980-1986 |
| Thomas Dean | 1986-1998 |
| Miles Hall | 1998-2007 |
| Russell Kent | 2008-2016 |
| Emanuel Oglice | 2017- |
